Ad Age | The Devil in Discourse by Dan Gardner

How Media Platforms Are Contributing To The Embarrassing State of Online Discussion

This content was originally published in Ad Age

By taking the right steps, confrontational exchanges can become constructive conversations.

No one needs to be told that online discourse can be toxic. Whether you are commenting or lurking, the discussion is often profane, stress-inducing and backed by all the facts and logic of a playground fight. According to our recent survey, conducted online by The Harris Poll among more than 2,000 U.S. adults, 70 percent of Americans feel that differing opinions in online conversations are more confrontational than constructive.

Dca887f2e14ce8514b9f343949593b67458244a2

Social psychologists have uncovered a range of causes: the anonymity of sites like Twitter and Reddit cause people to lose their inhibitions; a lack of physical and verbal cues removes the ordinary restraint imposed by politeness; and bots spewing negative comments compound the perceived permissibility of bad behavior.

Perhaps it’s time to go back to basics. The role of the media is to inform, educate and offer new points- of-view—and it should recommit to that. Discourse is a necessary and positive step to exposing people to new perspectives. But, rather than promoting healthy discourse, current media platforms actively discourage it in a number of ways:

Filtering content for users
Sites present what they think you’d like to see based on what you’ve seen before. The problem with this is that in a race for engagement, media sites tend to overdo it. Rather than suggest things you might like, along with other, more-random content, they eliminate everything else and create one-dimensional news feeds—and one-dimensional viewpoints. Our poll found that 81 percent of Americans believe online news content tends to be biased toward one point-of-view.

B2e06318205eacab9f8bc785df21a0d4f50ce761

Poorly aggregated content
Aggregators, like Facebook, do a poor job of presenting multiple sides of an issue. They tend to treat content as a commodity that can be pulled from anywhere and put in front of a reader, rather than a curated experience that can tell a story. This also results in homogenous feeds without alternative opinions. (Though, in fairness, the Facebook Journalism Project is a promising step that at least acknowledges the problem.)

Limited social participation on media sites
Storytelling formats in the media are often boring and formulaic. According to our poll, while 40 percent of millennials (ages 23-38) participate daily in online conversations about news and current events, less than one quarter (17 percent) of Gen X (ages 39-54) and Boomers (ages 55-73) combined do so. That’s likely because social engagement on media sites is primarily an afterthought and not a storytelling tool.

AdAge Data — 001.jpg

Creating positive discourse

To escape this quagmire, we must change the way these platforms work. Social media is about creating new forms of communication and it drives media innovation. So it can just as easily foster positive discourse as facilitate our current state of rancor.

This hasn’t been a priority up until now. Technology has so far created a single tool, the emoji, that communicates emotion and empathy. The emoji is, of course, about more than just this—it’s a whole new way to engage and connect. But we also need to be able to mimic tone, body language and familiarity in a way that brings true intimacy.

Most media sites rank comments using a primitive system in which other readers upvote the ones they like. Unfortunately, the people who vote are a subsection of any audience, and they tend to prefer more noxious and divisive comments. Instead, it’s time to start using artificial intelligence to promote comments. We can build smart systems that intentionally foster discourse, but in a positive social framework.

Friends vs. acquaintances
We can also redefine the meaning of online friendships. Social media makes the assumption that you have the same opinions as your friends and want to engage with the same things.

This brings several problems. First, online social groups are too large to be an appropriate sample size for your interests. Next, people collect online acquaintances at the same level as friends, but only true friends have the ability to be honest and open with one another. Social media innovation needs to focus on distinguishing real friends—the people we respect and listen to—from people we sat next to in high school.

Lastly, news aggregators can change the way they facilitate discourse. If media sites narrow their focus to be more meaningful to an audience, aggregators can understand and work across sites to highlight a full spectrum of viewpoints when curating an experience around a topic.

Discourse trumps discord
In recent years, we have seen a massive decrease in positive discussions and a corresponding increase in mud-throwing across the political and social spectrum. As a result, we should refocus our innovation efforts to promote real exchanges of views.

We need to expose people to alternative opinions and restore a degree of randomness and sanity to our online media feeds. I believe this needs to start with both media sites and social-media platforms, but it eventually needs to trickle down to everyone. We all could use more discourse and less discord in our lives.

Continue toThe Things We MakeProject

A Bold Vision for Healthcare

From patient-centric products to back-end systems for providers, we’re reimagining how healthcare is experienced.

BDG Floating
Bustle Digital Group

Modern Storytelling for Bustle Digital Group

A six year partnership launching new brands, reinvigorating classics, and redefining the digital media landscape.

Read More
  • Bold creative identities
  • Flexible and scalable design systems
  • Customizable card formats and interactive storytelling

Evolving the Financial Services Model

We're transforming an antiquated industry through cutting-edge design—and driving the future of finance forward.

Digital Media. Redefined.

Sky Italia Floating 2

Sky Italia | A Modern Digital Experience for the Italian Media Platform

Pool
CNN

Reimagining the CNN Magic Wall

Midterm elections 2018

Read More
  • One of the most critical, hotly contested, and highly watched midterm elections ever
  • Modernized a 10-year-old product with a new look & feel and enhanced core feature set
  • Rebuilt the technology from the ground up, focusing on data security and performance

Hours of on-air use for 2018 Midterms

13

Cultivating Community in Education & Government

We’re strengthening some of the most influential institutions through digital-first platforms and communications tools.

Shifting the Digital Fashion Paradigm

Vouge Fv2

Vogue | Creating a Smarter, Lighter, More Fluid and Fully-Responsive Vogue.com

Disrupting the Digital Sports Landscape

We do it for the love of the game—pioneering forward-thinking experiences for sports fans of every stripe.

Ad Age 0023Ad Age 0023Digiday1 0039

Recognition

  • Code and Theory

    Ad Age

    2020 Agency A-List
    Award Adage
  • Code and Theory

    Ad Age

    2020 Best Places to Work
    Award Adage
  • Code and Theory

    DIGIDAY

    2019 Creative Agency of the Year
    Award Digiday

All Work

Standard NBC News v4

NBC News | Launching Three News Verticals for the Media Giant

Jpmorganstory

J.P. Morgan | The First End-To-End Digital Platform in Commercial Real Estate

Mailchimp bythebooks standard

Mailchimp | A Digital Platform for Emerging Writers and Creators

Standard Car Spotting

MotorTrend | A Gaming App Experience for Car Connoisseurs

Standard Rivian

Rivian | Launching the World's First Electric Adventure Vehicle

MIT Sloan S

MIT Sloan School of Management | Crafting a Platform for Ideas Made to Matter

NYCEDC Sv2

NYCEDC | A New Hub for New Yorkers to Grow Their Business

Newtjmoverlay

The Jewish Museum | Bridging the Museum's Physical and Digital Experiences

Pulped S

Pulped | Providing Provocative, Alternative and Irreverent Video Content

United Tech Sv2

United Technologies | Uniting a Quarter Million Employees Under One Platform

Standard nuveen v2

Nuveen | Giving an Age-Old Investment Behemoth New Digital Prowess

USCC S v2

U.S. Chamber of Commerce | A Brand and Platform for Small Business Partnerships

Sunbrella s

Sunbrella | Redefining the Digital Textile Space

Coindesk Sv3

CoinDesk | Relaunching a Pillar of the Blockchain Community

Screen Shot 2020 04 29 at 12 08 36 PM

Theodore Roosevelt Presidential Library | Defining the New Digital Museum Experience

Axe S

Axe | An Iconic Men's Grooming Brand Known for Bold Marketing

Mccard

Mailchimp | Launching the New Digital Home for Tomorrow's Filmmakers

Xrxstandard

Xerox | Making Now Work: A New Campaign for a New Time

Nylon Standard

Nylon | Re-introducing an Iconic Publishing Brand

Input Standard

Input | A Brand New Destination About Technology in Our Lives

Dignity Health S

Dignity Health | Delivering a Best-In-Class Digital Experience

Skystandard

Sky Italia | A Modern Digital Experience for the Italian Media Platform

Terraton S v3

Indigo AG | Adopting Regenerative Practices with the Terraton Initiative

Bustle Standard Overlay

Bustle Digital Group | Modern Storytelling for Bustle Digital Group

Tegna CMS S

TEGNA | Creating a Centralized CMS for 39 Local News Stations

Facebook JP S

Facebook | Digital Tools to Revive and Inspire the Journalism Industry

Standard Nasdaq2

Nasdaq MarketSite | Nasdaq's Global HQ in NYC Gets a Pervasive Digital Infusion

NBC News Sv2

NBC News | A New Experience for Digital News

JPM Sv2

J.P. Morgan | Powering the Financial Leader's Acquisition Engine

Standard Euro Sport v2

Eurosport | Bringing Live Sports to the Palm of Your Hand

Standard MONCLER

Moncler | Bridging the Audience Gap with Moncler

Standard CNN Magic Wall

CNN | Understanding American Elections, One Visualization at a Time

The New Center Sv2

The New Center | A New Home Devoted to Saving the American Political Discourse

NBC Sports S

NBC Sports | Going Local: An NBC Sports App to Connect Fans and Home Teams

NY Life Sv2

New York Life | What 170 Years of Success Looks Like for Today's Evolving World

MCM Standard

MCM | Using Data to Empower an Iconic Luxury Brand for Growth

Standard NBC Today

NBC News | NBC's Iconic Morning Show Becomes a Digital Lifestyle Destination

Standard d10 X2

Citi Ventures | A Mobile Banking Service for a New Generation

Standard One night1

One Night | An App Experience Fit for One Night of Spontaneity

Standard Xfinity Mobile 4

Xfinity Mobile | Launching Comcast's Category-Breaking Mobile Service

Standard Outline v2

The Outline | The First Modern Mutation in Digital Publishing

Standard Ability Lab 3oo

Shirley Ryan AbilityLab | A Digital Platform Transforming the Medical Field

Standard CFRIII

The Council on Foreign Relations | Modernizing the Digital Presence of a Storied Institution

ABA S

American Bar Association | Modernizing One of the World's Largest Professional Organizations

Quest D S

Quest Diagnostics | Reinventing the Quest Digital Patient Experience

Standardc40 ok

C40 Cities Finance Facility | A Platform Built for a More Sustainable Future

Standard Stay Tuned1000

NBC News | Designing Snapchat's First Daily-News Program

Standard Fine Arts Museum ok

Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco | A Modern Identity System Uniting Two Eclectic Museums

Standard HRBLOCK

H&R Block | Block Advisors, a Financial Planning Service Built Around You

Standard Com AR Tsv2

Communication Arts | A New Era for the Iconic Inspirational Hub

Block Advisor Standard

Burger King | Introducing Grilled Dogs with Snoop Dogg

Standard WWE2

WWE | Building a Content Platform for Heavy Lifting

IRC Standard

International Rescue Committee | A Responsive Site for the World's First Responders

Standard Hearst Live

HearstLive | The World From a Hearst Point of View

Standard RIO v2

NBC | 16 Days With the World's Biggest Website

AMEX S

American Express | Turning an Acquisition Journey into a Bento Box

Standard Scene comp

The Scene | Introducing The Scene, Conde Nast's Ultimate Content Platform

Standard Guardian Labs2

The Guardian | A Native Platform for One of the World's Most Iconic Publishers

4 SQ S

Foursquare | Visualizing Data for the Platform's Pinpoint Ad Product

Consumer Reports S

Consumer Reports | Turning a Transactional Brand into a Shared Lifestyle Community

Standard thetruthv2

The Truth | Rebuilding a Revolutionary Brand for Modern Times

Standard Comcast 2

Comcast Corporate | From Corporate to Modern: Comcast's Brand New Platform

Standard GP2

Guggenheim Partners | A United Digital Vision for an Innovative Investment Manager

Standard Huffington Post 2

The Huffington Post | A Redesign for the 10th Anniversary

Standard BBC News v3

BBC News | Finite News Optimized for the Video Generation

Brand USA Sv2

Brand USA | Amplifying the USA as an International Travel Destination

Standard HR Expat2

H&R Block | A New Tax Offering for Expats

Standard Biz

Bloomberg | Creating a Smarter, Faster Bloomberg.com

Standard Motel Six

G6 Hospitality | A New, Reliable and Efficient Motel6.com

Standard Vanity Fair ok

Vanity Fair | Transforming a Summit Site into a Responsive, Flexible Destination

Standard NY Gov 2

NY.gov | A New Online Presence for New York State

Standard NY Senate 2

New York State Senate | A Digital Platform for Transparency, Engagement and Communication

Standard Vogue 2015

Vogue | Creating a Smarter, Lighter, More Fluid and Fully-Responsive Vogue.com

Standard Hearst Corporate

Hearst | Creating a Differentiated Yet Useful Site Experience

Standard Bloomberg Politics 2

Bloomberg | A Completely Original Take on Political Coverage

Standard GQ France2

Condé Nast | Distinguishing GQ France as a Leading Lifestyle Voice for French Men

Get in Touch

  • Find Us

    One World Trade Center,
    62nd Floor

    New York, NY 10007

    More Offices
  • Work With Us

  • Press

  • Careers

    See All Open Positions

Continue toSays a LotThe Things We Make

Says a Lot —

Latest

Codehealth pressasset
News — 

MM&M | Corporate Siblings C&T and Scout Health Join Forces

C Thealthstandard
Press — 

C&T Accelerates Innovation with Code and Theory Health

Mailchimp BTB Instagram 05
News — 

Adweek | A Literary Festival for Diverse Voices Finds a Home

Floating NYLON Orange
News — 

Communication Arts Names Nylon Webpick of the Week

Amy Carvajal hed 2020 0
News — 

Muse by Clio | 2 Minutes with Amy Carvajal, CCO at C&T

Campaign2
News — 

Campaign US | Pillow Talk with Xerox and Code and Theory

35674u 2 1
News — 

MediaPost | Theodore Roosevelt Presidential Library

Screen Shot 2020 05 08 at 3 41 25 PM
News — 

Podcast | Ad Age's 'Ad Block' featuring Dan Gardner

Get in Touch

  • Find Us

    One World Trade Center,
    62nd Floor

    New York, NY 10007

    More Offices
  • Work With Us

  • Press

  • Careers

    See All Open Positions